IndexGeneral OverviewRestatement of Author's ArgumentCritical AnalysisDefense of Philosophical PositionReferencesMy impression of Dennett's position throughout the story is that he is where he is told. When he began the experiment, he was supposed to be in Houston, then he was sent to Tulsa for the radioactive device and finally returned to the Houston laboratory. During the entire time of the experiment, I believe that Dennett was where his body was and not where his original brain was because he was still experiencing the scenarios he was in without feeling like he was in the laboratory. Furthermore, the only theory that in my opinion can relate to Dennett's experience is Memory Theory. In this theory it is said that we exist in time as long as we have memories of the past. In the experiment, Dennett clearly remembers what his favorite music was along with other events from the past. In this case, even if his brain was outside his body, he is still himself if we refer to the Theory of Memory. Finally, Dennett's thought experiment directly addresses the problem of personal identity. At first he understands who he is and why he is making decisions. Then, when his brain leaves his body and develops two sides with different personalities, he doesn't know who to be. The last part of the essay is about deciding which part of the brain wants to be the responsible adult or the adventurous human. In the end he decides to keep both aspects of himself, but this decision led him to reflect a lot because he was facing the problem of personal identity. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on "Why Violent Video Games Shouldn't Be Banned"? Get an Original Essay General Overview Dennett's condition leads to an understanding of the philosophy behind the human brain and body. The philosophical topic to be analyzed is the relationship between the body and the brain of an individual. A person's body, although controlled by the brain, can exist without the existence of the brain. The experiment done at Dennett demonstrates this result. Furthermore, an individual's common sense holds that a person's personal identification is intimately linked to the brain. To explain the statement, a person's thoughts occur in the brain. Any disruption to the brain would lead to disruption of reflexes. Through the analysis of the theory of memory and personal identity, it will be possible to understand the relationship between a person's body, brain and thoughts, as explained by the author. Restatement of the author's argument According to the author, an individual can find himself where the body is located but not where the brain is located. The whole experiment is demonstrated by Dennett's case when his brain was removed. Dennett's fictional tale, as explained and narrated by the author, involves a series of surgeries on the body and brain. This series aims to illustrate the theory of personal identity. In describing the entire scenario, Dennett's body had to be separated from his brain, due to the secret government mission he had to fulfill. After the separation of his brain and body, his brain was replaced by an artificial brain, connected to his primitive brain via radio waves. From the author's illustration, Dennett's body, although not directly connected to the brain, is associated with the brain via the artificial brain. It receives all the signals from the brain for action and also sends stimuli to the back of the brain. Through Dennett's hypothesis, he claims that he is not where his body is, and this is the center of the author's reasoning. Human personality is preserved in the brain even if the body is separated from the brain, and even when a different body connects to it againbrain, the individual's personality is maintained. As the author argues, Dennett's personal identity remains and was not disrupted when his brain was wired to a different body after the government mission. The theory applies to every individual as the human brain controls an individual's thoughts and personality, even if the body is changed, just like in Dennett's case.Critical AnalysisFrom the post and the author's argument, it is true that personal identity is determined by the brain and not by the body. Therefore, there is no relationship between the body and the brain. However, to counter this thesis, the body's action is determined by the brain. While it is clear that an individual's personal identity is determined entirely by the brain, will the individual's behavior affect the body in any way? Biologically, the stimulus impulse from the body is transmitted to the brain and at the same time the response impulses are sent back to the body for the same body to take an action (Perry et al. 125). Taking an example where the individual's personality leads to being talkative and quick to act, there will be a possible measure in case the brain sends impulses to the body. Through Dennett's experimental case, after having an accident, his entire body ceases to function with the artificial brain. Therefore, the process led to the shift of the point of view from the position of his body at the moment of the accident to the tank where the brain is located. It all means that there is a close relationship between the action of the body and the activity of the brain. The relationship between the body and the brain is well represented when an individual feels that he has been given a new body, as in Dennett's case. From memory theory, once a person is the same self and the same rational being, he retains the same personal identity. However, this can be refuted by the fact that the self is formed by the body and the results of a person's self are reflected in the actions of the body. With every small change in an individual's self, there will be a concomitant change in personality or personal identity. Once there is a change in personal identity, there will be an absolute change in the actions of the body. Since the brain is capable of realizing the individual's body, his identity can only be fully expressed in the original body and not with a counterfeit or different body. According to Perry et al. (2015, 130), the individual's personal identity may extend to consciousness, and thus the effect could only be seen in the original body but not in the counterfeit one (Perry et al. 130). From a psychological point of view, an individual's consciousness has an equation with memory and therefore personality also depends on knowledge. In most cases, a person is said to be conscious when his body is in the same place with the brain. The definition remains both literal and mental. The functions of the body are managed properly by the brain and therefore there is an association in their functions and activities. Mentally, an individual's thoughts should be determined by the existence of the brain and body in the same location. From the reality of an individual's personality arise various values ​​and virtues, and all are reflected in the activities of the body. For example, for a mean, rude, and unhappy person, the actions and words would represent the same characters (Hood, 15). Therefore, someone is not only his body, his emotions, his personality but also his brain, because all thoughts and decisions are determined by the brain. However, the body serves as a reflection and practical part of the human being that acts based on the brain's response to stimuli. Defense of the philosophical position Everyone tends to." (2015).